Distant Deities, Central Places. Reconsidering the “Extra-urban” sanctuary

International conference

Publicerad: 2023-03-29

distant deities 2023

The conference will take place as a hy­brid event, Thursday, April 6 – Saturday, April 8, 2023, physically in the lecture hall of the Italian Archaeological School at Athens, Parthenonos 14, and digitally on Zoom. Please reg­is­ter at con­fer­ences.sia.gr for par­tic­i­pa­tion.
For fur­ther in­for­ma­tion, con­tact
distantdeities@gmail.com or admin@conferences.sia.gr.

__________

Organizers:

- Axel Frejman, Uppsala University
- Christina Williamson, Groningen University
- Floris van den Eijnde, Utrecht University

__________

Ab­stract

Sanc­tu­ar­ies lo­cated at a dis­tance from ma­jor cen­tres of pop­u­la­tion in the an­cient world are con­ve­niently la­belled by schol­ars as ‘ex­tra-ur­ban’. Most schol­ars have an idea as to what kind of sanc­tu­ary this in­di­cates. But how ac­cu­rate is this im­age? How has the des­ig­na­tion of ‘ex­tra-ur­ban’ steered our think­ing about these spe­cial places of cult? What im­pli­ca­tions does the term bring with it, and what other dy­nam­ics might be left out of the pic­ture? By re­con­sid­er­ing our ter­mi­nol­ogy, this con­fer­ence aims to re­align our think­ing about these places of cults, and our po­si­tion­ing of them in the di­vine and hu­man land­scape.

Back­ground

Ma­jor sanc­tu­ar­ies be­yond the con­fines of the ur­ban cen­tre have long at­tracted the at­ten­tion of schol­ars. Early stud­ies keenly ob­served their role in ar­tic­u­lat­ing the nat­ural and hu­man land­scape (Sem­ple 1927, Still­well 1954, Lehmann 1954, Scully 1962). To­wards the later part of the twen­ti­eth cen­tury, they have been drawn into the ‘spa­tial turn’ of ar­chae­ol­ogy in a fo­cus on the ur­ban-rural axis of the an­cient (Greek) city, in an ef­fort to in­clude the coun­try­side as a con­sti­tu­tional fac­tor in the con­cep­tu­al­iza­tion of the po­lis. Com­bined with Christaller’s Cen­tral Place The­ory, this led to a strong core-pe­riph­ery con­cep­tu­al­iza­tion of an­cient Greek so­ci­eties, with the town (asty) as start­ing point, and con­cen­tric zones ra­di­at­ing out into its ter­ri­tory (chora). Rural sanc­tu­ar­ies that were once con­sid­ered re­mote or iso­lated in the land­scape are now gen­er­ally seen in the con­text of the chora, i.e. still within the sphere of ur­ban space, but at points near or far from the nu­cleus, and clas­si­fied ac­cord­ingly. Terms such as ‘in­tra­mu­ral’, ‘ex­tra-mu­ral’, ‘sub-ur­ban’, ‘ex­tra-ur­ban’, ‘in­ter-ur­ban’ and even the nega­tion ‘non-ur­ban’ (de Poli­gnac 1995) all ref­er­ence an ur­ban con­text and im­ply a di­rect cor­re­spon­dence be­tween the sanc­tu­ary and the po­lit­i­cal cen­tre to which the wider ter­ri­tory be­longed (Val­let 1968 (Magna Grae­cia), Ed­lund-Berry 1988 (Etruria), Schachter 1992 (Boi­o­tia)). Mythol­ogy and rit­ual prac­tices bound these sa­cred places to the ur­ban cen­tre and cen­tral pow­ers (e.g. Sourvi­nou-In­wood 1990; 2000).

A spe­cial place in schol­ar­ship is re­served for mon­u­men­tal shrines near the edges of ter­ri­tory and par­tic­u­larly po­lit­i­cal bor­ders. François de Poli­gnac’s sem­i­nal work La nais­sance de la cité grecque (1984/​1995) pre­sented the ‘bi-po­lar mod­el’, in which a ma­jor ‘ex­tra-ur­ban’ sanc­tu­ary at the pe­riph­ery of ter­ri­tory serves as coun­ter­weight to the ur­ban core and the de­vel­op­ment of the an­cient city. This drew at­ten­tion to the ‘fron­tier’ role of ‘ex­tra-ur­ban’ sanc­tu­ar­ies, so much so that the two qual­i­fiers are of­ten in­ter­changed. De Poli­gnac’s work is cer­tainly in­spi­ra­tional (e.g. con­tri­bu­tions in Al­cock & Os­borne 1994, also Graf 1996, Sinn 1996, Malkin 1996, Cole 2004), but it is also prob­lem­atic, with crit­i­cism aimed among oth­ers on its re­liance on the core-pe­riph­ery model and as­sump­tion of a mean­ing­ful ur­ban-rural bias in an­tiq­uity (Hall 1995, Polin­skaya 2006). It is es­pe­cially the ur­ban bias of the term ‘ex­tra-ur­ban’ that we wish to ex­am­ine more closely.

More re­cent stud­ies ex­tend their view well be­yond the city, con­sid­er­ing these mon­u­men­tal shrines in sa­cred land­scapes (e.g. Käp­pel and Pothou 2015, Häus­sler and Chiai 2019, Pa­pan­to­niou et al. 2019, Col­lar and Kris­tensen 2020). They are in many or most cases clearly cen­tres in their own right, of­ten at­tract­ing a wide va­ri­ety of wor­shipers and serv­ing as coun­cil houses, or hubs in net­works that are both po­lit­i­cal, re­li­gious, and eco­nomic in na­ture. But even though these sa­cred places are per­ceived as es­tab­lished places of au­thor­ity, of­ten reach­ing back into deep time, their role in the hu­man world is never sta­tic and sub­ject to chang­ing agen­cies that op­er­ate at sev­eral dif­fer­ent lev­els si­mul­ta­ne­ously. The need for a ‘thick de­scrip­tion’ that Häus­sler and Chiai 2019 ar­gue for sa­cred land­scapes is just as preva­lent re­gard­ing the sanc­tu­ar­ies them­selves.

Aims

With this con­fer­ence, we aim to bet­ter un­der­stand these mon­u­men­tal sa­cred places and their re­la­tion­ships to power net­works at a va­ri­ety of scales. Rather than con­cen­trat­ing on a sin­gle re­gion or mo­ment in time, we feel that a broad per­spec­tive is needed to truly re-eval­u­ate these shrines, and place them in their larger con­texts.

Top­ics may in­clude, but are cer­tainly not lim­ited to:

  • Ter­mi­nol­ogy, is Ex­tra-Ur­ban a use­ful term? When does it work and when is it mis­lead­ing or im­pos­ing a false model?
  • Ori­gins in place, why are sanc­tu­ar­ies lo­cated where they are, land­scape fea­tures?
  • An­cient un­der­stand­ing, how were sanc­tu­ar­ies dis­tin­guished from an emic per­spec­tive (e.g. ‘propolis’ sanc­tu­ary). How mean­ing­ful were ur­ban/​rural dis­tinc­tions in an­tiq­uity in re­la­tion to sa­cred places?
  • Change, tem­po­ral­ity and shift­ing sur­round­ings, change and de­vel­op­ment - e.g. sanc­tu­ar­ies be­com­ing ur­ban or be­com­ing rural (e.g. Malkin 1996, some sanc­tu­ar­ies ‘be­come’ ex­tra-ur­ban over time, or some ex­tra-ur­ban sanc­tu­ar­ies ur­ban.
  • Con­nect­ing shrines – par­al­lel sanc­tu­ar­ies in and out­side of town - e.g. ’dou­blets’ (Jost 1994; Lykaion/​Mega­lopo­lis, Brau­ron/​Athens, Eleu­sis/​Athens)
  • ‘Pan­hel­lenic’ sanc­tu­ar­ies and lo­cal po­lit­i­cal dy­nam­ics – how should we bal­ance the mag­ni­tude of shrines like Del­phi, Olympia, Isth­mia, Ne­mea be­tween their larger catch­ment area and the lo­cal com­mu­ni­ties that ad­min­is­ter them?
  • Func­tions, how do we square var­i­ous dif­fer­ing func­tions of sanc­tu­ar­ies, e.g. bor­der sanc­tu­ar­ies (sanc­tu­ar­ies be­tween set­tle­ments), re­li­gious cit­i­zen­ship (de Poli­gnac), sanc­tu­ar­ies as places of pro­duc­tion, but also more util­i­tar­ian and rit­ual needs.
  • In­te­gra­tion, how did sanc­tu­ar­ies in­ter­act with lo­cal and dis­tant so­ci­eties and set­tle­ments, economies and pol­i­tics. How do we un­der­stand tem­ple au­ton­omy, priestly agency and the re­la­tion­ship with lo­cal elites?
  • Wider per­spec­tives, e.g. east­ern tem­ple-states, Bronze Age peak sanc­tu­ar­ies (Crete), Etrurian sanc­tu­ar­ies, Ital­iote sanc­tu­ar­ies.
  • So­cial and eco­nomic im­pact, how did the sanc­tu­ary af­fect its sur­round­ings, e.g. sa­cred land­scapes, sa­cred lands, tem­ple lands, but also so­cial rit­u­als.
  • Be­yond the po­lis – re­cent dis­cus­sions ad­dress Greek re­li­gious prac­tices be­yond the po­lis (Mor­gan 2002, Kindt 2012, Con­stan­ta­kopoulou 2015, Ei­di­now 2020) help us out of the ur­ban / rural di­chotomy? Sanc­tu­ar­ies and non-ur­ban pow­ers.

Attached file: Schedule, Poster

Forskning/ Konferenser, seminarier & workshops

Athens Greek Religion Seminar

Athens Greek Religion Seminar

2024-01-31

Väl­kom­na till ett fö­re­drag av Wolf-Dietrich Niemeier, Deutsches Archäologisches Institut,...

Athens Greek Religion Seminar

Athens Greek Religion Seminar

2024-01-08

Välkomna till institutets seminarier om grekisk religion, Athens Greek Religion Seminar, för våren...

Athens Greek Religion Seminar

Athens Greek Religion Seminar

2024-01-23

Väl­kom­na till ett fö­re­drag av Olga Palagia, Athens universitet, med ti­teln A Cult Statue...

Spatial Approaches to Ancient Greek and Cypriot Landscapes

Spatial Approaches to Ancient Greek and Cypriot Landscapes

2023-12-19

Välkomna till workshoppen  Spatial approaches to Greek and Cypriot landscapes. Torsdag 25 januari,...

Athens Greek Religion Seminar

Athens Greek Religion Seminar

2023-12-04

Väl­kom­na till ett fö­re­drag av Despina Iosif, College Year in Athens, med ti­teln Pagans and...

Anatolian languages and bridges from the steppes

Anatolian languages and bridges from the steppes

2023-10-23

All welcome to the workshop  Anatolian languages and bridges from the steppes. The workshop takes...

Athens Greek Religion Seminar, in conjunction with Epichorios Research Day

Athens Greek Religion Seminar, in conjunction with Epichorios Research Day

2023-10-05

All welcome to the workshop  130 Years “Lakonische Kulte”: Current Trends and Future Perspectives...

Athens Greek Religion Seminar

Athens Greek Religion Seminar

2023-10-02

Väl­kom­na till ett fö­re­drag av Athanassia Zografou, Ioannina universitet, med ti­teln Homer,...

×
×

Vi använder cookies för att förbättra din online-upplevelse.
Genom att surfa på vår webbplats samtycker du till vår användning av cookies.

Läs mera